Discrimination, inflation,
and soft thinking
Auspsyc list. 13th February 2005 You don’t need to be very high on the IQ food-chain to understand that you can’t solve poverty by printing money. Yet lots of otherwise intelligent people seem to think that one can indefinitely indulge in feel-good actions without regard for their long-term consequences. Universities have a number of tasks, among them the spreading of knowledge and the maintenance of the quality of their degrees by setting a standard and failing those that don’t meet it. A permissive and tolerant attitude towards the latter has progressively led to B.A. degrees being nearly worthless to people who possess them. There are many other examples of a failure to discriminate leading to inflation in a value. A policy of rent control to benefit tenants leads to the housing rental market drying up. High minimum wages leads to an increase in unemployment. Unfair dismissal laws make businesses reluctant to take on permanent staff. Waiving debt for poor countries makes lenders reluctant in future. Soft decisions by judges dealing with illegal immigrants led to a rumour in the Middle East that Australia was an easy destination, and thousands set off in dangerous craft to try to find asylum here. Political pressures developed to deter this and correct the rumour, at great cost to the refugees and the country’s reputation. Soft decisions by judges, again, to award large sums to babies with impairments leads to sky-rocketing insurance premiums and a diaspora of obstetricians and others, with negative consequences for peri-natal care. The theme running through these various examples is the failure of well intentioned, caring, compassionate people to foresee that their policies and decisions would have negative consequences that would be considerably greater than the immediate effects they intended. I call that ‘soft thinking’. Soft thinkers can be found in all areas of life, not just among judges and universities. Social workers are famous for it. Many psychiatrists fit the pattern. Women and people from the left of politics seem more prone to it. But there are many men who are soft thinkers, and many women are not soft at all, especially when addressing behaviour by other women. Plenty of people from the left are firm thinkers as well. Paul Keating comes to mind. I used to teach medical students about the ideas of Martin Buber in his book ‘I and Thou’. He describes two modes of thinking: the ‘I -Thou’ mode, in which the perception of the ‘Other’ is based on encounter, empathy and shared presence in the ‘here and now’. The ‘I - He/She/It’ mode is based on detached objectivity and thinking about the ‘Other’ rather than relating to them. Good doctors must be able to do both, if not simultaneously, then at least in sequence. Doctors who only do the ‘I – Thou’ mode have a lovely bed-side manner, but forget to do a lumbar puncture or measure the serum creosote. Doctors who only do ‘I – It’ shield themselves with their white coats and fail to connect with the human in front of them. The trouble with ‘soft thinkers’ is not that they are caring and compassionate. It is that they fail to discriminate and think through the consequences of their decisions. The word ‘discrimination’ has lost its meaning in recent times. Anti-discrimination has been indiscriminately applauded, regardless of the discrimination that has been applied. Martin Luther King’s famous ‘I have a Dream’ speech [1] included the lines: "I have a dream that one day my four little children will live in a nation where they will not be judged by the color of their skin, but by the content of their character..." Many anti-discrimination activists would leave off the phrase about character. To turn to the recent debate about asylum seekers and their mental health. Any responsible politician has to address many dimensions of this problem, not just whether illegal immigrants are unhappy about being denied entry to Australia. Any politician in a democracy who neglected these other issues would lose an election. Psychiatrists who only address mental health issues when participating in a debate about asylum seekers should not be surprised when their opinions are ignored. The philosopher Anthony Flew's book Thinking about Thinking
- or do I sincerely want to be right? uses some snappy titles to catch
the spirit of certain errors of argument. To say that illegal immigrants are unhappy, or even depressed, is not, in itself, sufficient to resolve the debate on the subject. Part of my objection to those psychiatrists who are campaigning against mandatory detention in the name of the RANZCP and scientific research is that they threaten some distinctions that I believe should be defended. The first is the integrity of the RANZCP. If people start speaking on its behalf, using inaccurate titles, saying things that they are not authorized to say on behalf of the whole College, then the value of any statement made on behalf of the College becomes degraded. We pay significant fees to belong to the College, and I resent the value of that membership being diminished. I also resent the failure of the College to protect the integrity of its public relations. Lack of discrimination leads to inflation. The second is the integrity of medical scientific research. Scientific statements purport to be statements of fact. The whole scientific endeavour is an attempt to prevent falsehoods entering the body of what is believed to be true. The appropriate attitude to science is doubt, and the attempt by scientists to disprove their theory. If the attempt fails, the theory remains the ‘truth’ for the time being. The authors of the ANZJPH article (2) claim to prove that 100% of their sample has a mental disorder, and that most of these disorders were caused by the detention. If we have been informed correctly, the subjects were recruited for the research because they were involved in appeals against the government and that they were seeking medico-legal reports to help their appeals. The people providing the reports were associated with the researchers, who were known by all of us, and presumably the subjects, to be politically active in campaigning against the government because of the mental health issues associated with the detention camps. These refugees have come through a series of presumably traumatic experiences to get to where they are. They have been victims of mistreatment at the hands of Saddam Hussein, the Taliban or the Iranian theocrats. They have travelled in leaky boats through waters infested with pirates and sharks. It would be easy to imagine that many possible causes of psychiatric disorder might have occurred well before they arrived in Australia. With such a plethora of reasons why research on the detainees’ psychiatric disorders might be open to bias of one sort or another, it is incumbent on the researchers to explicitly guard against bias. By failing to do that adequately, they have diminished the status of all psychiatric epidemiology. The ANZJPH and the UNSW are also tainted by the exercise. Failure to discriminate leads to inflation. Soft thinkers commonly use the algorithm, ‘spot the victim and be nice to them’. They easily fit into the Karpman Drama Triangle (3) in the rescuer position. Anyone questioning their wisdom, their approach or the consequences of their actions is quickly allocated the role of persecutor. Notice that I haven’t expressed an opinion about what should be done about illegal immigrants. I have confined myself to criticizing soft thinkers and people who fail to discriminate between significant distinctions, and the ways that their errors lead to inflation of ideas that matter. Their errors also commonly lead to poor outcomes for the very people they claim to be trying to help. David Straton References. 1) I Have a Dream speech by Martin Luther King, August 28th 1963 2) Psychiatric status of asylum seeker
families held for a protracted period in a remote detention centre in
Australia. 3) The basic concept underpinning the
Karpman
Drama Triangle is the connection between responsibility and power,
and their relationship to boundaries. |