Galileo, Darwin and the Australian Health System
David Straton
Auspsyc list. 17 July 2004
Message 4942

The list has recently been bubbling over 'What does Australia want?' A general lament about the state of the public mental health system.

I have been reading 'Galileo's Daughter' by Dava Sobel (author of the must-read 'Longitude') which was given to me by my own daughter, and also 'Fossils, Finches and Fuegians' by Richard Keynes, about Darwin's voyage on the Beagle, in preparation for a trip to the Galapagos.

I have often found that juxtaposing books and ideas can produce interesting collisions. These three topics did for me, and I propose to share one such collision with the list.

The theme that emerged for me was the idea of the 'Apostatic Moment'. That moment when someone loses faith in the conventional way of seeing the world, and adopts another, unconventional or heretical, which later becomes seen as obviously true.


Galileo lived at a time when the universe was seen as Earth-centred. This was the belief of Aristotle and Ptolemy. The Catholic Church considered that this was supported by the Bible, and that opposing views were heretical. Nicholas Copernicus was an obscure Polish cleric who published an alternative heliocentric theory in 1543. He promptly died, thus avoiding persecution. He put forward no cohesive argument, or empirical evidence for his theory.

Galileo, however, invented the telescope, and undertook careful observations of Venus, Jupiter's moons, sunspots, tides and other matters. He assembled considerable evidence for the Copernican theory. He wrote his 'Dialogue' which was published in 1632, in which the competing ideas were discussed in role-play by three imaginary characters. The book was banned by Pope Urban VIII, Galileo was put under house arrest and subjected to the Inquisition. He was lucky not to be tortured.


Charles Darwin was a dropout medical student who was a big worry to his family. He was just 23 when he joined HMS Beagle, and 26 when it reached the Galapagos Islands in 1835. It was there that he had the insights that lead to him later publishing 'On the Origin of Species' in 1859. In ways that echo the relationship between Galileo and Copernicus, Charles Darwin was a meticulous collector of evidence for a theory that his own grandfather, Erasmus Darwin, had foreshadowed in a poem, 'The Temple of Nature', which was published posthumously in 1803.

http://jquarter.members.beeb.net/moreedarwin.htm

See also the book 'The Lunar Men' by Jenny Uglow.

http://jquarter.members.beeb.net/morelunar.htm

During the voyage of The Beagle, Charles Darwin collected a lot of evidence from plants, animals and fossils. Quite late in the journey he was toying with the idea that there might be two creators, to explain the differences between the ecosystems on the two sides of the Andes, in Argentina and Chile.

But somehow in the Galapagos, he saw another way to join up the dots. I was particularly interested to try and understand how that happened.

Facts I had inadequately appreciated before I went there:

1) The Galapagos Islands are a critical distance from the South American mainland. About 1000 kilometres. This is within the survival range for some floating reptiles such as giant tortoises and iguanas, but not carnivorous mammals. The effect was to provide a filter that permitted reptiles, marine birds, sealions, and a few birds such as finches to reach the islands, but effectively no mammalian predators.

They say a cricket pitch has to be 22 yards to work. If it were longer, the batsmen would have the advantage. If shorter, the bowler.

2) The islands were never connected to a mainland. They emerged from the sea by volcanic eruption some 3 - 5 million years ago. Anything living there had to cross 1000 kilometres of ocean.

3) The islands are a fair distance from each other. One crossing we did took 12 hours. The flight of, say, finches from one island to another can't occur very often. Thus it has been possible for finches on one island to evolve into one ecological niche that is different to the niche occupied on another island. If the islands had been closer, the finches would have been more homogenous and less differentiated.

So picture a diagram in which the 1000 km ocean crossing operates as a filter which permits a very limited range of life-forms to arrive. If it had been longer, nothing would have survived the trip. If shorter, mammal predators would have got there too and spoiled the party. Then the spread of islands permits differentiation from a common finch ancestor to several varieties. An explosion starburst radiates from a narrow entry point. It became possible for Darwin to see the gradient of differentiation particularly clearly. In a more stable polycultural ecosystem one would see variety, but one might not see evolution.

So he suddenly saw it. The penny dropped. The apostatic moment.


I used to be a socialist. From an early age, after reading The Jungle, by Upton Sinclair, I was convinced that capitalism was evil and that State Socialism was the answer.

Somewhere along the line, the behaviour of the Soviets in Czechoslovakia disabused me of that, and I was part of the radical student movement in the late 1960s and 70s that was critical of both capitalism and Soviet socialism.

But I still believed in the sort of democratic socialism represented by the welfare state models of Scandinavia, the UK, Australia and New Zealand.

The recent debate on this list about the failure of so-called 'public mental health services' has evoked a number of different responses. I sense that most psychiatrists believe that more money should be spent on them. More beds. More staff. Better management. We should lobby harder. Educate politicians. Educate the public, the taxpayers.

Others want to blame someone and punish them. Send them to jail. Form a union and pressure the government.to do better for our vulnerable patients.

I've had an apostatic moment myself.

I think the so-called public health system should be eliminated.

I also propose a boycott of the terms 'Public' and 'Private'. They are misleading. The word 'Private', in particular, carries a lot of elitist innuendo that really does not apply in discussion of Australian Health arrangements.

Consider the following statements:

a) The 747 with 500 passengers on board waited for a private Lear jet to take off.

b) She drove her black BMW 4WD to take her children to their private school.

c) He visited a doctor in private practice and was bulk-billed.

The third one stands out. It does not deserve to carry the same semantic baggage as the first two.

I suggest that the two systems in this country be called:

  • Federally subsidized [Medicare card system]

and

  • State Socialist [State Health departments].

The socialist paradigm, under which states own the means of production and the services for dealing with the health and education needs of the population, has lost credibility. It doesn't work. It provides no mechanism for the elimination of dysfunctional elements, which therefore persist. The consumers of such systems are disempowered. Mismatches between demand and supply are dealt with by queues and waiting lists. Supply is managed by crisis and uproar.

The socialist ideal held credibility between October 1917 and November 1989, when the Berlin Wall fell. Since then, we have just been watching the washing up. It is high time that the failure of socialism was reflected in the abandonment of the State Socialist Health system in Australia.

There are several elements of the present system that are unacceptable.

1) The vertical fiscal imbalance, under which the Commonwealth government raises taxes, transfers money to the States, and the States spend it, produces multiple problems. This is recognized by both sides of politics. Cost-shifting is rife.

'Jurisdictional inefficiencies associated with Federal and State Governments having different responsibilities are the major barriers to quality and cost effectiveness in our health system.' Australian Health Reform Alliance.

Both Tony Abbott and Mark Latham have been in the news in the last few months deploring the waste the system creates.

http://www.abc.net.au/news/newsitems/s1062493.htm

http://afr.com/articles/2004/07/16/1089694560215.html

Facts about Medicare costs.

2) The existence of two systems creates a situation in which when doctors get frustrated with the State Socialist system, they move to the Federally Subsidized system. Leadership is lost. Nurses (who have much less flexibility of movement) rise through the ranks to fill the power vacuum.

I discussed this issue on this list on 14 December 2003.

Psychoanalysing the Health System

Auspsyc message 3295 with responses in following messages.

3) Patients are disempowered under the State Socialist system.


Imagine that you have been using a particular type of treatment for your patients for, say, about 90 years. Lets call it Treatment 'A'. Then about 20 years ago another treatment becomes available. Lets call it Treatment 'B'. Both are then used.

Patients on treatment 'A' get lots of problems. Around the world, the philosophy behind treatment 'A' gets discredited.

Patients on treatment 'B' do pretty well. It becomes widely recognized as being among the worlds 'best practice'.

Now those on treatment 'A' hit a particularly severe crisis. Would you:

1) Adjust the dose of treatment 'A'.
2) Arrest the doctors using treatment 'A' and put them in jail for
not being more ethical.
3) Abandon treatment 'A' and treat all patients with treatment 'B'.


So what do I suggest?

The Commonwealth Minister for Health should announce that from a certain date, the Commonwealth will stop the truckloads of money being sent to the State Ministers for Health.

He or she should instruct the HIC to create Item numbers for all hospital and community health activities, such as bed costs, theatre costs etc.

From the specified date, the Commonwealth dollars will stop arriving at the top of the system, but instead will arrive at the front doors, the A&E depts etc, in the form of the patients Medicare cards.

In the short term, State Governments may chose to continue to operate the State Hospitals. But they would be free to sell shares in them and sell them off to others to run.

The item numbers could be used selectively to steer resources in the direction of undersupply, for example rural services, home visiting, the severely mentally ill, etc.


Cheers

David Straton